Shaner’s Pizza: Bringing Big Taste and Hometown Warmth to Sarasota Springs, FL

Sarasota Springs’ Choice for Real, Quality Pizza

Pizza lovers in Sarasota Springs know where to go when they want fresh, flavorful, made-to-order pies. With former professional athlete Shane Rawley guiding the craft, each pizza is created with care, quality ingredients, and a true dedication to great taste. From easy takeout nights to relaxed dine-in meals, this neighborhood spot delivers big flavor and a warm, welcoming vibe.

Call Today

Shane Rawley: A Passion for Great Pizza in Sarasota Springs, FL

Shane Rawley’s dedication to honest, flavorful cooking shines through every pie at Shaner’s Pizza in Sarasota Springs. Each pizza starts with scratch-made dough, fresh ingredients, bold sauces, and a perfectly baked crust. From classic favorites to inventive creations, every slice reflects his commitment to quality and authentic flavor.

View Menu

Sarasota Springs’ Spot for Fresh, Flavor-Forward Pizza

Sarasota Springs diners know they can count on Shaner’s Pizza for pies made with care - from daily-made dough to toppings chosen for taste and quality. With former professional athlete Shane Rawley leading the craft, every pizza achieves the perfect blend of texture and flavor. From comforting classics to bold specialty creations, each slice is prepared to deliver a memorable experience.

A Place to Slow Down and Enjoy Great Pizza

This neighborhood favorite offers more than a delicious meal - it creates a warm, welcoming space for connection. Families unwind after busy days, friends meet up for an easy dinner, and regulars return for the friendly service they know they’ll find. Whether grabbing takeout or settling in for a relaxed meal, guests enjoy an atmosphere that feels genuine, familiar, and inviting.

Your Go-To Place for a Truly Great Slice

Locals know that unforgettable pizza starts here - with hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, and a perfectly crisp bake that reflects the passion former pro athlete Shane Rawley puts into every recipe. Known for bold flavors, a relaxed atmosphere, and a genuine neighborhood vibe, this favorite eatery brings together great food and real warmth in every slice.

Sarasota’s Favorite Thin Crust Pizza Since 1991!

Order Delivery