What happens when a Major League Baseball player retires? Some become coaches or commentators, others start new careers entirely. But for former pitcher Shane Rawley, the answer was simple: make pizza. Located in Sarasota, FL, Shaner's Pizzeria is a beloved favorite amongst locals and visitors alike. And what makes it unique is the man behind the counter - a former baseball player turned pizza maker. In this blog post, we'll explore the story behind Shaner's Pizzeria and how Rawley's passion for food and lifelong learning is reflected in every pizza he serves.

An Intimate and Welcoming Atmosphere

Walking into Shaner's Pizzeria, located in Gulf Gate Village, Sarasota, customers are greeted with an intimate and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant and sports bar is filled with photographs of baseball stadiums, Topps cards, and pennants featuring team logos from different eras of the game, creating a cozy environment. Customers can enjoy the restaurant's warm vibe and personal touch from former Major League Baseball player Shane Rawley, who is often present, chatting with patrons and sharing stories.

A Major League Pitcher Turned Pizza Maker

Before becoming the owner of Shaner's Pizzeria, Shane Rawley spent 12 seasons as a Major League Baseball player. Starting his career with the Seattle Mariners in 1978, he later played for the New York Yankees, Philadelphia Phillies, and Minnesota Twins. Rawley fell in love with Sarasota after visiting a friend who had moved to the area, and has been a Sarasotan ever since. After retiring from baseball, he turned his passion for food into a business, opening Shaner's Pizzeria in 1991.

Perfecting the Thin Crust Pizza

Rawley's passion for food is evident in every pizza he makes. He set out to bring the thin, crispy style of pizza that he grew up with in Racine, WI, to Sarasota. Rawley spent hours perfecting his dough recipe, which has become the cornerstone of Shaner's menu. The thin crust pizza is what sets Shaner's Pizzeria apart from the competition. Rawley is constantly experimenting with new ingredients and techniques to make his pizza even better.

A Personal Touch

Rawley's dedication to his craft extends beyond the food. As a former Major League Baseball player, he understands the importance of building relationships and connecting with people. That's why he's always there to share stories and talk with patrons, adding a personal touch to the dining experience.

Rawley's goal is to make every customer feel at home and have a great time, with good food and good atmosphere. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, Rawley and his team are dedicated to providing exceptional service and making your dining experience unforgettable. The restaurant's intimate environment, filled with pictures of Rawley on the pitching mound and baseball stadiums, coupled with Rawley's friendly and personable demeanor make Shaner's Pizzeria a must-visit spot in Sarasota.

A Lifelong Learner

Rawley is a firm believer in lifelong learning, and his passion for food and customer service is reflected in every pizza he serves. As a player, he sought to learn from the best and gain different perspectives, which he now applies to his restaurant business. Rawley believes his customers appreciate his work ethic and commitment to quality, which is why Shaner's Pizzeria is a beloved favorite amongst locals and visitors alike.

Discover the Story Behind the Perfect Pie

Experience the story behind Shane Rawley's Shaner's Pizzeria for yourself. You can find them at 6500 Superior Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231, or give them a call at (941) 927-2708 for take out or delivery. Indulge in the best thin-crust pizza in town, and let Rawley's passion for food and commitment to customer service make your dining experience unforgettable.

The Story of Shaner's Pizzeria: From the Pitcher's Mound to the Perfect Pie